I finally had a chance to read William Kristol's NYT November 10, 2008 op-ed, "GOP Dog Days?" It's hilarious (and somewhat disturbing) that on election night he truly believed that...
"This year’s exit polls suggested a partisan shift but no ideological realignment...In other words, this was a good Democratic year, but it is still a
center-right country. Conservatives and the Republican Party will have
a real chance for a comeback — unless the skills of the new president
turn what was primarily an anti-Bush vote into the basis for a new
liberal governing era."
Then came the Puppy Moment, when the President elect told his daughters, "You have earned that new puppy that is coming with us to the White House." And Kristol writes:
"I gulped.
Not out of my deep affection for dogs, fond of
them though I am. But because while we’ve all known that Obama is a
very skillful politician, he hasn’t until now been a particularly
empathetic one. Competence plus warmth is a pretty potent combination.
Suddenly visions of the two great modern realigning presidents —
Franklin Roosevelt (with his Scottish terrier Fala) and Ronald Reagan
(with his Cavalier King Charles spaniel Rex) — flashed before my eyes.
Maybe a realignment could be coming."

FDR and Fala in the Oval Study, December 20, 1941 via The National Archives

Ronald and Nancy Reagan take a stroll with Rex, AP photo 1986 via USA Today
Kristol is rocked even more by President-elect Obama's first press conference when he discusses the First Puppy issue...
"Here, in a few sentences, Obama did the following: He deepened his bond
with every dog lover in America. He identified with every household
that’s tried to figure out what kind of dog to get. He touched every
parent with a kid allergic to pets. He showed compassion by preferring
a dog from a shelter. And he demonstrated a dry and slightly
politically incorrect wit by commenting that 'a lot of shelter dogs are
mutts like me.' "
Finally, his delusions of center-right voters swinging the conservatives back into office are shattered...
"It could be a tough four or eight years for conservatives."
His advice...
"It wouldn’t hurt for Governors Sarah Palin, Mitch Daniels, Bobby Jindal
and the other possible 2012 G.O.P. nominees to begin bringing some
puppies home for their kids."
My advice: Bill, tell your protégé, Sarah Palin, to stop being photographed with bloody, dead animals.
Read Kristol's full article here.